I am impressed with this compact collection. Most of the colors work for me, but I do not use them all. I use the darkest as an eye liner and the next two dark ones as shadows. I apply them with a brush. They last all day, do not smear even when I rub my eyelid. I wish that the darkest was a bit darker, but it works. I use the third lightest color as a concealer and apply it with the sponge applicator included with the kit. The packaging is very sturdy and attractive. Even the box is sturdy and printed inside with the logo design. Very attractive and very useful product. I would purchase it again.